in , ,

Against the Odds: Mayfield battling history in first NFL start

Ken Blaze-USA TODAY Sports

If there was any real drama surrounding Hue Jackson’s starting quarterback decision, that all ended early Monday morning. The Cleveland Browns will officially welcome No. 1 overall pick Baker Mayfield to the starting lineup for Sunday’s game against the Oakland Raiders.

Mayfield took over for an injured and floundering Tyrod Taylor last Thursday night against the New York Jets, leading a second-half come-from-behind victory from a 17-0 deficit. He completed his first three NFL passes for 47 yards and finished 17-of-23 for 201 yards.

Related: NFL Betting Guide

As impressive as Mayfield played (and his stat line looked), history is against him when it comes to his first, official NFL start. The last No. 1 quarterback to win his first start was David Carr back in 2002, which also happened to be the first game in franchise history for the Houston Texans. Carr led the expansion team to a 19-10 victory over their cross-state rival, the Dallas Cowboys. They wouldn’t pick up another victory until Halloween weekend.

The fact is, since the 1970 merger, only four No. 1 picks who were quarterbacks pocketed a victory in their first start and John Elway’s shouldn’t count since he opened the game 1-for-8 in 1983 and was benched for Steve DeBerg. Elway posted a passer rating of 0.0, which, of course, means he was a total bust and a bum. What ever happened to that loser?

The other guys who won games are Michael Vick and Jim Plunkett. There’s really no indication of future success there. Elway had the worst game as a first start and ended up with the best career. Plunkett is a Hall of Famer, but that’s because of what he did with the Oakland/Los Angeles Raiders later in his career. For the team that drafted him No. 1 overall, the Boston/New England Patriots, he was considered kind of a bust. Carr was a bust and Vick had an up-and-down career.

If you want to factor in your future betting prospects with Mayfield, here’s some historic info for you to factor in. Only three rookie No. 1 overall quarterbacks posted a winning record against the spread in their first season — Andrew Luck, Cam Newton and Sam Bradford. Bradford was 10-6 against the spread back in 2010 and Luck went 11-5 both straight up and against the spread in 2012. Newton was 9-7 against the spread in 2011.

The last two No. 1 overall picks were not nearly as fortunate. Jameis Winston went 7-9 against the spread in 2015 and Jared Goff went 0-7 straight up and against the spread in 2016.

History of No. 1 pick quarterbacks in their first start:

2016: Jared Goff (L 14-10)
2015: Jameis Winston (L 42-14)
2012: Andrew Luck (L 41-21)
2011: Cam Newton (L 28-21)
2010: Sam Bradford (L 17-13)
2009: Matt Stafford (L 45-27)
2007: JaMarcus Russell (L 30-17)
2005: Alex Smith (L 28-3)
2004: Eli Manning (L 14-10)
2004: Carson Palmer (L 31-24)
2002: David Carr (W 19-10)
2001: Michael Vick (W 20-13)
2000: Tim Couch (L 26-9)
1999: Peyton Manning (L 24-15)
1993: Drew Bledsoe (L 38-14)
1990: Jeff George (L 26-10)
1989: Troy Aikman (L 28-0)
1987: Vinny Testaverde (L 44-34)
1983: John Elway (W 14-10)
1975: Steve Bartkowski (L 23-20)
1971: Jim Plunkett (W 20-6)
1970: Terry Bradshaw (L 19-7)

The Browns have opened as a +2.5 underdog at Oakland next Sunday via BetDSI and that’s a pretty friendly line. Being a home team alone is worth three points, so the fact that the Raiders are hosting and aren’t at least getting that shows plenty of respect for the team from Cleveland and their rookie signal caller.

Correlating and interesting stats surfaced when we continued researching rookie quarterbacks and their performances as starters.

No. 1 picks as starters during their rookie season are 72-155 overall (.317 winning percentage) and 83-97-4 ATS (46.1%). Only four of the 22 quarterbacks posted winning ATS records, and just one of the 22 (Andrew Luck) posting a winning record in his rookie year.
The most recent first overall selection, Jared Goff, went 0-7 SU and 0-7 ATS in his seven starts as a rookie.

Record of No. 1 pick quarterbacks in their rookie seasons as starters:

Terry Bradshaw (3-5)
Jim Plunkett (6-8)
Steve Bartkowski (4-7)
John Elway (4-6)
Vinny Testaverde (0-4) (1-3 ATS)
Troy Aikman (0-11) (4-7 ATS)
Jeff George (5-8) (6-7 ATS)
Drew Bledsoe (5-7) (7-4-1 ATS)
Peyton Manning (3-13) (6-10 ATS)
Tim Couch (2-12) (6-7-1 ATS)
Michael Vick (1-1) (1-1 ATS)
David Carr (4-12) (7-8-1 ATS)
Carson Palmer (0-0) (0-0 ATS)
Eli Manning (1-6) (3-4 ATS)
Alex Smith (2-5) (3-4 ATS)
JaMarcus Russell (0-1) (0-1 ATS)
Matt Stafford (2-8) (2-7-1 ATS)
Sam Bradford (7-9) (10-6 ATS)
Cam Newton (6-10) (9-7 ATS)
Andrew Luck (11-5) (11-5 ATS)
Jameis Winston (6-10) (7-9 ATS)
Jared Goff (0-7) (0-7 ATS)

What do I expect from Mayfield in his first start? Oakland’s defense hasn’t stopped much of anybody, but they’ve also played three good teams — the Los Angeles Rams, Denver Broncos and Miami Dolphins. I expect Mayfield to play well, but asking him to pick up his first victory on the road, on the West Coast, against a Raiders team (and head coach Jon Gruden) looking for its first victory of the season is too tall of an order.

If I’m picking this game today, I say the Raiders win and cover, with Mayfield joining a very long list of good No. 1 overall quarterbacks who lost their first NFL start.

Written by Adam Greene

Adam Greene is a writer and photographer based out of East Tennessee. His work has appeared on Cracked.com, in USA Today, the Associated Press, the Chicago Cubs Vineline Magazine, AskMen.com and many other publications.

Friday Afternoon Quarterback: NFL Week 4 Spread Picks and Locks

St. Louis Cardinals vs. Chicago Cubs Free Pick 09/29/18